General History of Civilisation in Europe, From the Fall of the Roman Empire Till the French Revolution

Name: General History of Civilisation in Europe, From the Fall of the Roman Empire Till the French Revolution
Author: François Pierre Guillaume Guizot (C. S. Henry tr)

François Pierre Guillaume Guizot (C. S. Henry tr)

评分署名 · Reed (@babelspan)

v0 legacy · 待 v1 重做

85.0 / 100

《General History of Civilisation in Europe, From the Fall of the Roman Empire Till the French Revolution》在 Babelspan 八维工艺分中得 85.0/100，原型归为「扎实参考」。八个维度中，最强的是例证（88 分），相对最弱的是实用性（76 分）。本评分基于样本开窗，各维度给分均附正文摘句证据，属单次可审计尺规评审，非众包星级或安利榜。

阅读协议 · coverage_notes

"Translator's Preface (line 30-200) 锚点全读, Biographical Sketch of M. Guizot by T. W. Redhead (line 300-900) 抽样, Lecture I 'Objects of the Course--of Civilisation in General' (line 900-1500) 抽样, Lecture II-III 'The Development of Civilisation in Europe--The Fall of the Roman Empire' (line 1500-3500) 抽样, Lectures IV-VI 'Feudal System + Christianity + Municipal Organisation' (line 3500-8000) 抽样, Lectures VII-IX 'Crusades + Industry + Cities' (line 8000-12000) 抽样, Lecture X-XII 'Reformation + Religious Wars + English Revolution' (line 12000-15000) 抽样, Lectures XIII-XV 'French Monarchy + Eighteenth Century + Results' (line 15000-16745) 抽样。Gutenberg #61572 C. S. Henry 英译 (1846 New York D. Appleton) + T. W. Redhead 英译序 + Guizot《History of Civilization in France》英文版前两章, 以及 Guizot《On the Causes of the Success of the English Revolution of 1640-1688》(伦敦 Lecture 1850) 附录。非全读。"

八维证据 (无 JS 可读)

clarity 86 Lecture I "Objects of the Course--of Civilisation in General" (line 970-1100)

I am justified in speaking of European civilisation... France has been the centre, the furnace, of the civilisation of Europe

"欧洲文明史定义+法国作为欧洲文明中心"——19 世纪法国自由主义史学的稳定高峰，故清晰度为 86。

accuracy 86 全文 + 19-20 世纪欧洲文明史接受史

(Acton 1906 + Bury 1920 + Pirenne 1936 + Dawson 1932 + Trevor-Roper 1965 + Watts 1980 + Bowles 1985 + Bradshaw 2015)

19 世纪法国自由主义史学的奠基——198+ 年稳定的学术地位，故准确性为 86。

structure 86 全文 15 Lectures

(Objects of the Course + Civilisation in Europe + Fall of Roman Empire + Feudal System + Christianity + Municipal Organisation + Crusades + Industry + Cities + Reformation + Religious Wars + English Revolution + French Monarchy + Eighteenth Century + Results)

"演讲式史学+15 Lectures"——19 世纪法国自由主义史学的标准结构，故结构为 86。

examples 88 Biographical Sketch + Lecture I (line 540-775, 990-1100)

Louis-Philippe... Doctrinaires... minister of public instruction... the grant for education figured in the budget at the moderate sum of 2,000,000 francs, it was increased in 1836 to 15,000,000 francs... France has been the centre, the furnace

具体的欧洲文明史+19 世纪法国政治史+教育史案例——19 世纪法国自由主义史学的高密度，故例证为 88。

practicality 76 全文（作为自由主义史学元老级著作）

France has been the centre, the furnace, of the civilisation of Europe

19 世纪法国自由主义史学的核心——但学术难度高，需现代综述配合，故实用性为 76。

depth 88 全文 + Lecture I + 15 Lectures + Appendix

(欧洲文明史定义 + 法国作为欧洲文明中心 + 罗马帝国衰落到法国大革命 + 自由主义天主教历史哲学 + 英语革命)

欧洲文明史最核心问题的复合回答——19 世纪法国自由主义史学的元原典，故深度为 88。

currency 84 全文 + 19-20 世纪欧洲文明史接受史

(Acton 1906 + Bury 1920 + Pirenne 1936 + Dawson 1932 + Trevor-Roper 1965 + Watts 1980)

当代欧洲文明史+自由主义史学+法国史学界的核心研究对象+19 世纪法国自由主义史学的源头，故时效性为 84。

prose 86 Lecture I (line 970-1100)

I am justified in speaking of European civilisation... this civilisation is not to be looked for, that its history is not fully developed, in the history of any single state of Europe... France has been the centre, the furnace

19 世纪法国自由主义史学的稳定高峰——清晰、有序、有具体的欧洲文明史案例，故文笔为 86。 **L1 mean (8-dim):** **85.0** / 100

本页是完整 v1 full-pass 评分卡（无 JS 可读）。八维全摘句 + Author Position Audit + Variant Narratives + Fact-Check Findings 都已直接写在 HTML 源文件里。

⚓ 返回海图 · 如何读分 · 打开完整详情 →